AIToday
AI Safety & AlignmentAI Regulation & PolicyAI WeeklyPublished: Nov 4, 2026, 01:00 JST

CPS cited fake case R v J in child rape review, court finds

Send on LINE
CPS cited fake case R v J in child rape review, court finds

3 Key Points

  1. What happened

    The High Court heard that a written record by senior Crown prosecutor Ravinder Dhillon cited a 2024 authority, R v J, that "does not exist"; Dhillon said she meant R v JTB [2009] UKHL 20.

  2. Why it matters

    The judges called the error "unsatisfactory" but ruled the point "unarguable" and said it did not affect the outcome, so the challenge to continuing the prosecution failed.

WHO IT HITSProsecutors and court staff who rely on written legal records face scrutiny over AI-generated citations, while defence lawyers may use such errors to challenge CPS decisions.

Not sure about something? Ask the AI

Questions and answers are published on this page.

Summaries like this, every morning.

Context & Analysis

The High Court's ruling follows a July admission by the Crown Prosecution Service that it had put hallucinated cases produced by AI before the High Court in an extradition appeal. In that earlier instance, the errors surfaced before the hearing and were found to have had no impact on argument or the judgment. This time, the fabricated authority appeared in a written record compiled by senior Crown prosecutor Ravinder Dhillon, and the claimant sought to add a fifth ground of challenge based on three references to it. The court did not explain how the citation entered the record, nor did it indicate any action it would take. Instead, it focused on whether the legal principles purportedly derived from the nonexistent case were wrong in law, and having rejected those criticisms, it dismissed the application while granting permission on two other grounds. The pattern of AI-generated citations reaching the High Court, now twice acknowledged by the CPS, may draw attention to how legal records are compiled and checked, though the court itself treated the error as immaterial to the result.

FAQ
What was the fictitious case called?
The court said the written record cited a 2024 authority called R v J, which "does not exist"; the prosecutor said she had meant R v JTB [2009] UKHL 20.
Did the fake citation change the court's decision?
No. The judges found the ground "unarguable" and said the error was "unsatisfactory" but did not matter to the outcome of the challenge.
Has the CPS made similar errors before?
Yes. In July, the CPS admitted putting hallucinated cases produced by AI before the High Court in an extradition appeal.
Send on LINE

AI news that matters for your work, delivered every morning.

Pick your industry and the AI tools you use, and get news related to your work every day.

Free · 30 seconds with Google · unsubscribe anytimeWhat is AIToday? →

Ask AI

Ask AI anything about this article. The AI reads this article, earlier AIToday articles, and Wikipedia, and cites its sources. Q&As are published on this page for other readers too.

Questions and answers are published on this page.

Related Articles

Next articleAI chatbots wrong in 40% of election answers, Forum AI finds